Voting Home / Great Meals / BEST Traditional American
| Nominee | Address | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Al's Corner Restaurant | 545 west tuscarawas ave. Barberton, OH | #4 |
| Amish Door Restaurant | 1210 Winesburg St Wilmot, OH | #1 |
| Belgrade Gardens | 401 E State St Barberton, OH | #9 |
| Bialy's at the Lake | 493 Portage Lakes Dr Akron, OH | #15 |
| Canal Grille | 2223 Locust St S Canal Fulton, OH | #6 |
| Dutch Valley Restaurant | 1343 OH-39 Sugarcreek, OH | #12 |
| Geisen Haus | 6955 Promway Ave NW Canton, OH | #14 |
| Grandma's Alpine Homestead Restaurant | 4450 OH-557 Millersburg, OH | #19 |
| Hartville Kitchen | 1015 Edison St NW Uniontown, OH | #2 |
| Hopocan Gardens | 4396 Hopocan Avenue Ext Barberton, OH | #12 |
| Hudson's Restaurant | Multiple Locations | #3 |
| John's Grille | 2749 Cleveland Ave NW Canton, OH | #8 |
| Little Chicago Bistro & Sports Pub | 585 Market Ave N Canton, OH | #18 |
| Pufferbelly | 152 Franklin Ave Kent, OH | #5 |
| Reserve Inn | 30 W Streetsboro St Hudson, OH | #16 |
| Top of the Viaduct | 607 Lincoln Way W Massillon, OH | #10 |
| Waterloo Restaurant | 423 E Waterloo Rd Akron, OH | #7 |
| White House Chicken | Multiple Locations | #11 |
| Wil's Grille & Pub | 1644 Turkeyfoot Lake Rd Barberton, OH | #17 |
2011 Winners + −
BEST Brunch BEST Chinese BEST Family Restaurant BEST Italian BEST Mexican BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Traditional American2009 Winners + −
BEST Brunch BEST Chinese BEST Family Restaurant BEST Italian BEST Mexican BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Traditional American2008 Winners + −
BEST Brunch BEST Chinese BEST Family Restaurant BEST Italian BEST Mexican BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Traditional American